A Framework for the Private Governance of Frontier Artificial Intelligence
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.70777/si.v2i2.14519Keywords:
agi governance, artificial intelligence safety, agi value alignment, libertarian, agi safetyAbstract
This paper presents a proposal for the governance of frontier AI systems through a hybrid public-private system. Private bodies, authorized and overseen by government, provide certifications to developers of frontier AI systems on an opt-in basis. In exchange for opting in, frontier AI firms receive protections from tort liability for customer misuse of their models. Before detailing the proposal, the paper explores more commonly discussed approaches to AI governance, analyzing their strengths and flaws. It also examines the nature of frontier AI governance itself. The paper includes consideration of the political economic, institutional, legal, safety, and other merits and tradeoffs inherent in the governance system it proposes.
References
Hayek, Friedrich A. von. Law, Legislation, and Liberty, Volume 1: Rules and Order. The University of Chicago Press. 1973.
Lévi-Strauss, Claude. The Savage Mind. The University of Chicago Press. 1962.
Stahl et al., “Challenges of AI Alignment—Negotiating the Plurality of Values in AI Ecosystems through Bricolage,” Scientific Reports, 2025.
Madhavan, Guru. Wicked Problems: How to Engineer a Better World. 2024.
Senator Ted Cruz, remarks to the Special Competitive Studies Project, March 2025.
Verdegem, Pieter. “Dismantling AI Capitalism: The Commons as an Alternative to the Power Concentration of Big Tech.” AI & Society, April 2022.
Andreesen, Marc. “The Techno-Optimist Manifesto.” October 2023.
Ball, Dean W. “Decentralized Training and the Fall of Compute Thresholds.” Hyperdimensional. October 2024.
Reuel et al. “Open Problems in Technical AI Governance,” July 2024
Anderljung et al., “Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety.” November 2023.
Mill, John Stuart. On Liberty. 1859.
Hayek, Friedrich A. von. The Constitution of Liberty, Chapter 4 (“Freedom, Reason, and Tradition”). 1960.
Buchanan, James. The Limits of Liberty: Between Anarchy and Leviathan. 1975.
Nozick, Robert. Anarchy, State, and Utopia. 1974.
Hubinger et al. “Sleeper Agents: Training Deceptive LLMs that Persist Through Safety Training.” (January 2024).
Anthropic, “Simple Probes Can Catch Sleeper Agents” (April 2024).
Lapid, Raz et al. “Open Sesame! Universal Black Box Jailbreaking of Large Language Models” (September 2023).
Sharma, Mrinank et al. “Constitutional Classifiers: Defending Against Universal Jailbreaks across Thousands of Hours of Red Teaming” (February 2025).
Zaremba, Wojciech et al. “Trading Inference-Time Compute for Adversarial Robustness.” (January 2025).
Kapoor et al.,“On the Societal Impact of Open Foundation Models”.
Executive Office of the President, Executive Order 14110. “Safe, Secure, and Trustworthy Development and Use of Artificial Intelligence.” 88 FR 75191, 2023-24283. (rescinded)
European Union Artificial Intelligence Act, Chapter V, Article 51. “Classification of General-Purpose AI Models as General-Purpose AI Models with Systemic Risk.”
Safe and Secure Innovation for Frontier Artificial Intelligence Models Act (SB 1047). California Senate, 2023-2024 legislative session.
DeepSeek-AI, “DeepSeek-R1: Incentivizing Reasoning Capability in LLMs via Reinforcement Learning.”
OpenAI, “OpenAI o1 System Card.
Anthropic, “Claude 3.7 Sonnet System Card.”
Ball, Dean W. “An Extraordinary Alien: OpenAI’s o1 Challenges AI Policy.” Hyperdimensional. September 2024.
Wu, Tongwong et al. “Continual Learning for Large Language Models: A Survey.” February 2024.
Dean, Je: (Google Research). “Introducing Pathways: A Next-Generation AI Architecture.” October 2021.
Hooker, Sara. “On the Limitations of Compute Thresholds as a Governance Strategy.” July 2024.
Ball, Dean. W and Ketan Ramakrishnan, “On Entity-Based Regulation in Frontier AI Governance” (working title), Mercatus Center, April 2025.
Williams, Sophie et al., “On Regulating Downstream AI Developers” (March 2025).
“Concerning Consumer Protections in Interactions with Artificial Intelligence Systems,” Colorado SB 205 (signed May 17, 2024).
European Union Artificial Intelligence Act, Chapter III, Article 27, “Fundamental Rights Impact Assessment for High-Risk AI Systems.”
“A Longer-Term Vision for AISI” in Ball, Dean W. “On the US AI Safety Institute.” Hyperdimensional. March 2025.
Brundage et al. “The Malicious Use of Artificial Intelligence.” February 2018.
Brynjolfson, Erik and Tom Mitchell. “What Can Machine Learning Do? Workforce Implications.” Science vol. 358, issue 6370. December 2017.
Eloundou, Tyna et al. “GPTs are GPTs: An Early Look at the Labor Market Impact Potential of Large Language Models.” August 2023.
Buchanan, James M. and Gordon Tullock. The Calculus of Consent: Logical Foundations of Constitutional Democracy. 1962.
Stigler, George J. “The Theory of Economic Regulation.” Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science, Vol. 2 No. 1, Spring 1971. RAND Corporation.
Krueger, Anne. O. “The Political Economy of the Rent-Seeking Society.” American Economic Review, June 1974.
Carpenter, Daniel and David Moss. Preventing Regulatory Capture: Special Interest Influence and How to Limit It. Cambridge University Press. 2013.
Laffont, Jean-Jacques and Jean Tirole. “The Politics of Government Decision-Making: A Theory of Regulatory Capture.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol. 106, No. 4. Oxford University Press, November 1991.
Khan, Lina M. “Amazon’s Antitrust Paradox.” The Yale Law Journal, Volume 126, No. 3. January 2017.
Wilson, James Q. (Ed). The Politics of Regulation. 1980.
Bureau of Economic Analysis. Gross Output by Industry. Accessed March 30, 2025.
Section 13, “An Act Relating to Artificial Intelligence Systems,” SB 199, Nevada Senate.
Barton, Benjamin H. and Deborah L. Rhode. “Access to Justice and Routine Legal Services: New Technologies Meet Bar Regulators.” Hastings Law Journal, Volume 70, Issue 4.
Rauch, Daniel E. and David Schleicher. “Like Uber, but for Local Government Regulation: The Future of Local Regulation of the ‘Sharing Economy.’” The Ohio State Law Journal, Volume 76, Issue 4. 2015.
Gillian Hadfield and Jack Clark in their paper “Regulatory Markets: The Future of AI Governance.” (April 2023).
Pahlka, Jennifer. Recoding America: Why Government is Failing in the Digital Age and How We Can Do Better. 2023.
Hinkley, Sara. “Technology in the Public Sector and the Future of Government Work.” University of California-Berkeley Labor Center. January 2023.
United States Senate Joint Economic Committee. “National Debt Growth.” March 2025.
United States Census Bureau. “Annual Survey of State Government Finances.” October 2024.
Bureau of Industry and Security, Department of Commerce. “Commerce Implements New Export Controls on Advanced Computing and Semiconductor Manufacturing Items to the People’s Republic of China (PRC).” October 7, 2022.
Hammond, Samuel. “Supporting the Bureau of Industry and Security.” Testimony delivered to U.S. House Committee on Appropriations, Subcommittee on Commerce, Justice, Science, and Related Agencies. May 2024.
Office of Congressman Jason Crow. “Reps. Crow and Kean Introduce Bill to Modernize the Bureau of Industry and Security’s IT Systems.” August 2024.
Selinger, Marc. “BIS Could See 10.5% Funding Cut in 2025, Senator Says.” Export Compliance Daily. March 2025.
Frontier Model Forum (FMF). “FMF Announces First-of-its-Kind Information-Sharing Agreement.” March 2025.
Aarne, Onni et al. “Secure, Governable Chips: Using On-Chip Mechanisms to Manage National Security Risks from AI & Advanced Computing.” Center for a New American Security. January 2024.
Sastry et al. “Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence.” Centre for the Governance of AI. February 2024.
Triolo, Paul. “A New Era for the Chinese Semiconductor Industry: Beijing Responds to Export Controls.” American Affairs. Spring 2024.
Grunewald, Erich. “AI Chip Smuggling into China: Potential Paths, Quantities, and Countermeasures.” Institute for AI Policy and Strategy. October 2023.
Bureau of Industry and Security: “BIS is also concerned regarding the potential for China to use IaaS solutions to undermine the e:ectiveness of the October 7 IFR controls and continues to evaluate how it may approach this through a regulatory response.”
“Implementation of Additional Export Controls: Certain Advanced Computing Items; Supercomputer and Semiconductor End Use; Updates and Corrections,” 88 FR 73458, 2023-23055, pgs. 73458-73517. October 2023.
Bureau of Industry and Security. “Framework for Artificial Intelligence Diffusion.” 90 FR 4544, 2025-00636, pgs. 4554-4584. January 2025.
Lee, Timothy B., Dean W. Ball, and Lennart Heim. “Lennart Heim on the AI Diffusion Rule.” AI Summer. January 2025.
Krouse, Sarah et al. “US Wiretap Systems Targeted in China-Linked Hack.” The Wall Street Journal. October 5, 2024.
Jaghouar, Sami et al. “INTELLECT-1 Technical Report.” December 2024.
Datta, Arnab and Tim Fist. “Compute in America: A Policy Playbook.” Institute for Progress, February 2025.
Bureau of Justice Statistics, “Tort Cases in Large Counties.” United States Department of Justice, 1992.
A Concise Restatement of Torts, Third Edition. 2013.
Weil, Gabriel. “Tort Law as a Tool for Mitigating Catastrophic Risk from AI.” January 2024.
Choi, Bryan H. “Negligence Liability for AI Developers.” Lawfare. September 2024.
Sharkey, Catherine. “Products Liability for Artificial Intelligence.” Lawfare. September 2024.
Ramakrishnan, Ketan et al. “US Tort Liability for Large-Scale Artificial Intelligence Damages: A Primer for Developers and Policymakers.” RAND Corporation. August 2024.
Safe and Secure Innovation for Frontier Artificial Intelligence Models Act (SB 1047). California Senate, 2023- 2024 legislative session.
Vandall, Frank J. “Constructing Products Liability: Reforms in Theory and Procedure.” Villanova Law Review, Volume 48, Issue 3. 2003.
Section 402(A), and all of the Restatement (Second) of Torts,
Restatement (Third) of Torts: Products Liability in 1997.
Escola v. Coca Cola Bottling Co., 24 Cal.2d 453, 150 P.2d 436 (Cal. 1944) (Traynor, J., concurring)
Greenman v. Yuba Power Products, Inc., 59 Cal.2d 57, 27 Cal. Rptr. 697, 377 P.2d 897 (Cal. 1963)
Calabresi, Guido. The Costs of Accidents. 1970.
Huber, Peter W. Liability: The Revolution and Its Consequences. 1990.
Kagan, Robert A. Adversarial Legalism: The American Way of Law. 2001.
Epstein, Richard A. “Products Liability as an Insurance Market.” The Journal of Legal Studies, Volume 14, Number 3. December 1985.
Priest, George L. “The Current Insurance Crisis and Modern Tort Law.” The Yale Law Journal, Volume 96, Number 7. June 1987.
Congressional Budget Office. “The Economics of US Tort Liability: A Primer,” page xi. 2003.
McQuillan, Lawrence J. and Hovannes Abramyan. US Tort Liability Index: 2010 Report. Pacific Research Institute. 2010.
Shavell, Steven. “Liability for Harm Versus Regulation of Safety.” The Journal of Legal Studies, Volume 13, Number 2. June 1984.
Calabresi, Guido. A Common Law for the Age of Statutes. Harvard University Press. 1982.
Andrej Karpathy, “Intro to Large Language Models.”
Waldon v. Arizona Public Service Co., No. 14-55076 (9th Cir. 2016).
Climate Disasters: Civil Actions (SB 222). California Senate, 2025-2026 legislative session.
Handmer, Casey. “The Los Angeles Wildfires Are Self-Inflicted.”
Powell, Lars et al. “Rethinking Prop 103’s Approach to Insurance Regulation.” International Center for Law & Economics. November 2023.
Schwartz, Victor E. et al. “Deep Pocket Jurisprudence: Where Tort Law Should Draw the Line.” Oklahoma Law Review, Volume 70, Number 2. 2018.
Hinton, Geoffrey. 2024 Nobel Prize in Physics Banquet Speech.
Sam Altman remarks to United States Senate Judiciary Committee, Subcommittee on Privacy, Technology, and the Law. Tech Policy Press.
Bengio, Yoshua et al. “Managing Extreme AI Risks Amid Rapid Progress.” Science. May 2024.
Multistate.AI. “AI Legislation.” March 2025.
Chandler Jr., Alfred D. The Visible Hand: The Managerial Revolution in American Business. 1977.
Hadfield, Gillian and Jack Clark. “Regulatory Markets: The Future of AI Governance.” 2023.
Williamson, Oliver E. The Economic Institutions of Capitalism. 1985.
Tirole, Jean. “A Theory of Collective Reputations (with Applications to the Persistence of Corruption and to Firm Quality.” The Review of Economic Studies, Volume 63, Number 1. January 1996.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
Categories
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Dean Ball
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
